A serious car accident can leave more than just physical injuries behind. Many people walk away without a scratch but find themselves struggling with anxiety, fear, and even depression. These emotional and psychological effects are just as real and can be just as damaging as any physical injury.
In New Jersey, emotional distress car accident compensation may be available under certain conditions. However, due to the state’s no-fault insurance rules, not every injured person can pursue damages for emotional harm. Understanding when compensation is possible and what factors determine the amount is key.
Emotional Distress and New Jersey’s No-Fault System
New Jersey follows a no-fault insurance system. That means after a car accident, your own Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage pays for your medical bills and certain other economic losses, regardless of who caused the crash.
However, compensation for emotional distress or pain and suffering is not included in standard no-fault PIP benefits. To pursue car accident stress compensation from a third party, such as the at-fault driver, an injured person must meet one of the legal thresholds for filing a personal injury lawsuit.
These thresholds are known as the “verbal threshold” or “limitation on lawsuit” option (N.J.S.A. 39.6A-8(a)), and most New Jersey drivers select it to reduce their insurance premiums. But it limits the ability to sue unless your injuries fall into one of these categories:
• Death,
• Dismemberment,
• Displaced fractures,
• Significant disfigurement or scarring,
• Loss of a fetus, or
• Other permanent injury (based on objective medical evidence).
If your emotional distress stems from one of these qualifying injuries or your policy does not include the verbal threshold limitation, you may be eligible to seek compensation beyond your PIP coverage.
What Is Emotional Distress in a Legal Claim?
Emotional distress refers to the psychological impact of an accident. Common symptoms include:
• Anxiety or panic attacks,
• Sleep disturbances or nightmares,
• Mood swings or irritability,
• Depression or hopelessness,
• Flashbacks or post-traumatic stress (PTSD), and
• Difficulty concentrating or functioning day-to-day.
In legal terms, these symptoms fall under “pain and suffering,” a broad category of damages that covers both physical discomfort and mental anguish.
Mental health records, diagnoses from psychologists or psychiatrists, and testimony from loved ones or coworkers can help demonstrate how your emotional well-being has changed since the accident.
Valuing Emotional Distress in New Jersey Car Accident Cases
There is no universal formula for calculating emotional distress. Every case is different, and compensation depends on several key factors.
1. Severity and Duration of Symptoms
Mild, short-term anxiety may not carry the same weight as ongoing PTSD or depression. Courts and insurance companies often consider how disruptive your symptoms are to your daily life and whether treatment, like therapy or medication, is required.
2. Connection to Physical Injury
Emotional distress is often taken more seriously when it is tied to a serious physical injury. For example, someone recovering from permanent disability or chronic pain may experience significant emotional trauma as a direct result.
3. Medical and Psychological Evidence
Objective evidence strengthens emotional distress claims. Mental health treatment records, diagnostic reports, and expert testimony from treating professionals can show the extent of your psychological trauma. The more comprehensive your documentation, the more weight your claim may carry.
4. Impact on Daily Life and Relationships
An inability to return to work, take care of your children, or enjoy normal social activities can increase the value of your claim. Courts will often evaluate how the distress has altered your routine and diminished your quality of life.
5. Prognosis for Recovery
If your emotional trauma is expected to persist long-term, the projected cost and impact of continued treatment may increase your potential emotional distress car accident compensation.
Typical Compensation in Pain and Suffering Claims
When pain and suffering are part of a lawsuit, compensation varies widely depending on the facts of the case. While there is no fixed dollar amount, emotional distress typically falls under the broader category of non-economic damages.
Ultimately, New Jersey juries or insurance adjusters determine compensation based on the strength of the evidence, the credibility of the victim, and the overall impact of the accident on the person’s life.
Why Clients Trust Petro Cohen, P.C.
At Petro Cohen, P.C., car accident claims aren’t just part of what we do; they’re a core focus of our practice. Our team has consistently been recognized for legal excellence and professional integrity. We’ve earned the highest rating (AV®) from Martindale-Hubbell for legal ability and ethical standards, and our attorneys have been named among New Jersey Super Lawyers® year after year. With decades of experience handling complex insurance disputes, including uninsured and underinsured motorist claims, we’re known for getting results while treating our clients with compassion and respect. From the first conversation through resolution, we fight for your rights and prioritize your recovery every step of the way.
Loading...